Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 11 MIN READ

Remote SOS filings: which states got there fastest

Four weeks into lockdown, the state filing offices that were already digital-first barely noticed, and the paper-heavy ones are visibly breaking

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
11 min read Updated
Contents 9 sections
  1. Delaware: already remote, barely noticed
  2. Wyoming: no missed days, same $100
  3. California: bizfile held, then got bigger
  4. Massachusetts: a real sprint
  5. New York: the front end cratered
  6. Alabama: the dual-filing mess amplified
  7. Pennsylvania: online up, paper slowed
  8. The one-month lesson
  9. Sources

ne month after most of the country went home, the Secretary of State offices that were already digital are mostly operating as if nothing happened, and the ones that still ran on paper are visibly underwater. Remote SOS filing in April 2020 is not a new capability; it is the same capability the 2019 benchmark described, now under the kind of load test it never expected.

The short version: Delaware, Wyoming, California, Colorado, and Florida absorbed the shift without a meaningful degradation in service. Massachusetts moved faster than expected, converting a paper-dominant operation to online filing inside two weeks. Alabama's structural mess got worse because probate courthouses closed. New York, which was already the national laggard, has effectively stopped accepting new LLC filings at normal speed. Pennsylvania's bureau is up but slower. This is a field report.

Delaware: already remote, barely noticed

Delaware's Division of Corporations was digital-first before it was fashionable, and that posture is the reason the state is still filing on the same clock it kept in February. Governor John Carney declared a state of emergency on March 12, 2020, and modified it on March 22 to close non-essential businesses and ask Delawareans to stay at home. The Division did not, in any operational sense, go offline. The eCorp filing portal, the document-upload service, and the expedited tiers all continued to run. The Division's posted guidance in early April asked visitors to use online and telephone services rather than walk in, but the walk-in counter has never been how serious volume filed anyway; the serious volume comes through registered agents with eCorp accounts, and those accounts keep working whether the front desk is staffed or not.

The reason this is boring is the reason it matters. Delaware's fee schedule still lists One Hour Service at $1,000, Two Hour Service at $500, Same Day at $100 to $200, and Next Day at $50 to $100, each on top of the $90 formation fee. The cutoff times still hold. The state still publishes a document-filing window Monday through Thursday from 7:45 a.m. to 11:59 p.m. Eastern and Fridays to 10:30 p.m. The state that hosts nearly two-thirds of the Fortune 500 did not need a continuity plan for corporate filings because its corporate-filings operation was already the continuity plan. When a Manhattan corporate associate tries to form a Delaware entity at 9:30 p.m. on a Thursday in April 2020, the experience is indistinguishable from February.

Wyoming: no missed days, same $100

Wyoming's Business Division never paused. The state's filing portal at wyobiz.wyo.gov continued to form LLCs at the ordinary $100 state fee (plus the roughly 2.4% processor charge that brings the effective total to around $102.40), and the ordinary turnaround remained same-day during business hours. Wyoming never built an expedited tier because the routine tier is already fast, and the small population of the state means even a full-volume surge during the early pandemic weeks did not produce anything resembling a backlog. The privacy pitch is the usual reason to pick Wyoming; in April 2020, the quieter pitch is that the office is simply open.

California: bizfile held, then got bigger

California's response is more interesting than "they stayed open," because California actually moved. On March 18, 2020, Secretary of State Alex Padilla's office announced it was shifting as many staff as feasible to telework while keeping the Sacramento and Los Angeles buildings open. Two days later, on March 20, the Sacramento public counters closed; drop boxes in the first floor rotunda remained for in-person deliveries, and bizfile stayed fully operational at bizfile.sos.ca.gov.

The harder move came on March 27, when the office launched the Corporation Formation Online Submission Tool. Corporation formation had been one of the remaining paper-or-mail processes in California; LLC formation had been online since May 2018, and the Statement of Information for LLCs had migrated online through bizfile over 2018 and 2019, but corporation formation itself still moved on paper. The March 27 launch pulled that last major paper workflow onto the web in the middle of the first week of statewide lockdown. Padilla followed on April 21 with press release AP20:039 announcing a revamped online Statement of Information tool for corporations, which included an address-reuse feature and a search-and-select flow for registered agents. In the previous fiscal year, the office had processed roughly 955,000 required Statement of Information filings plus another 32,000 amendments, which had been paper-only.

The operational signal is that California, already home to one of the strongest state portals, treated the early weeks of the pandemic as a reason to accelerate rather than defer a launch. For a founder forming a California entity in April 2020, bizfile is faster today than it was in February, and the experience is entirely in a browser.

Massachusetts: a real sprint

Massachusetts was the surprise. The Secretary of the Commonwealth's Corporations Division had a working online filing system before the pandemic, but the economics discouraged its use. The Certificate of Organization for an LLC was $500 by mail and $520 online: a $20 online premium that had the effect of pushing the serious volume back onto paper for anyone comfortable with a stamp. Most of the Commonwealth's routine filing load in February 2020 was still arriving at One Ashburton Place in Boston on paper.

That stopped working quickly. Governor Charlie Baker's emergency declaration on March 10 and subsequent stay-at-home advisory on March 24 made walk-in filing impractical, and the Corporations Division pivoted within roughly two weeks to treat the online filing system as the default channel. The fee schedule itself did not change in this window; what changed was the Division's posture toward the online path. The public-facing guidance began treating the online Certificate of Organization as the ordinary route rather than the more expensive alternative, and in-person services at One Ashburton Place moved appointment-only or email-first. The operational gap between paper and online closed fastest in Massachusetts of any laggard in the country, and it closed without a fee change that would have required legislative action.

The math still favors Delaware or a home-state filing for most founders forming in April 2020, but the April Massachusetts operation is a materially better product than the February one, and an out-of-state lawyer handling a Massachusetts matter can now realistically file without a trip to Boston. That was not true a month ago.

New York: the front end cratered

New York was already the national laggard in June 2019 and in February 2020, and the February modernization update described a pilot for online LLC formation that had been "in development" for more than a fiscal year and had not launched. In April 2020, that pilot is still not live. What has changed is that the paper front end the Department of State continued to rely on has broken under load.

The mechanics: a domestic New York LLC is formed by delivering Articles of Organization to One Commerce Plaza in Albany by mail, fax, or in-person. The $200 state fee is cheap, but the delivery channel is physical. With Governor Andrew Cuomo's March 20 executive order (EO 202.8) tolling statutory deadlines for 228 days and directing non-essential state workforces home, the physical front end of the Department of State's Division of Corporations thinned out. The mail does not stop arriving; the processing of the mail slows down. Four weeks in, practitioners filing new LLCs and amendments are seeing confirmation timelines stretch from the pre-pandemic range of roughly five to ten business days into something longer that the Department has not quantified publicly.

The downstream effect on the Section 206 publication requirement is the one that stings. N.Y. LLC § 206 requires notice in two newspapers for six consecutive weeks and a Certificate of Publication filed within 120 days of formation. The 120-day clock starts when the Articles of Organization are filed, not when the filer receives the paper confirmation. EO 202.8 tolls statutory deadlines, which covers the 120 day window as a legal matter, but the practical effect is that New York LLCs organized in late March have a clouded formation date and a filing-receipt delay that compounds the publication cost. A would-be New York LLC in April 2020 is looking at a meaningfully slower formation than a comparable Delaware entity qualified into New York as a foreign LLC, and at this point the latter is the advice most New York corporate lawyers are giving.

The larger story is that the February 2020 observation now reads as a decision. A pilot not launched through a fiscal year was a schedule question. A pilot not launched through the worst four weeks of paper filing in New York's modern history is an organizational one.

Alabama: the dual-filing mess amplified

Alabama's structural problem in normal times is that a Certificate of Formation has to be delivered first to the Judge of Probate in the county of the registered office under Title 10A of the Code of Alabama, recorded locally at a fee of at least $50, and then transmitted to the Secretary of State in Montgomery for the separate $100 state fee. In February 2020, eleven of Alabama's sixty-seven counties supported online filing through to the probate step: Baldwin, Colbert, DeKalb, Elmore, Geneva, Houston, Jackson, Madison, Montgomery, Morgan, and Tuscaloosa. The other fifty-six required a trip to the courthouse.

When the courthouses closed, so did the path to filing in those fifty-six counties. The Alabama Judicial System issued a sequence of administrative orders between March 13 and April 30, 2020, limiting in-person court proceedings and moving many functions to remote operation; probate offices in most smaller counties do not have remote filing infrastructure, and the Secretary of State's online pass-through system only works where the probate judge has joined the Alabama Interactive platform. Secretary John Merrill's public target of reaching all sixty-seven counties by 2022 looked like a two-year project in February. In April, for the counties that are not yet online, it is blocking formations outright or forcing them into a workaround that involves picking a registered office in one of the eleven live counties.

The Alabama case is the single cleanest illustration of why structural filing mechanics matter. Louisiana's 2019 geauxBIZ rebuild, which looked like a niche procurement story last summer, is now load-bearing; Alabama's still-incomplete rebuild is, in four weeks, the difference between a formation that happens in April and one that has to wait.

Pennsylvania: online up, paper slowed

Pennsylvania's Department of State runs the Bureau of Corporations and Charitable Organizations, and its online filing system for business entities remained operational through March. Governor Tom Wolf's March 19, 2020 order closing non-life-sustaining businesses did not close the Bureau, but it did substantially thin the staff handling paper mail at 401 North Street in Harrisburg. For a filer using the online Business Filing Services portal, turnarounds held. For a filer dropping paper in the mail, they did not. The Bureau's guidance through the first four weeks consistently directed filers to the online path and treated paper as the degraded channel rather than the default. The $125 LLC registration fee and the ten-year decennial report cadence remained unchanged.

Pennsylvania is worth noting because it is neither a top-tier portal state nor a structural laggard; it sits in the middle, and the pandemic has compressed the middle toward the top. The states that had functional online systems regardless of their relative polish have mostly held together. The states that relied on paper have mostly cracked.

The one-month lesson

An uncomfortable truth for state-agency planners: the pandemic did not cause the gap between the top and bottom of the filing-portal league table; it widened a gap that was already there. Every state that looks competent in April 2020 looked competent in February. Every state that looks broken in April was the one being flagged in June 2019 as the state to watch. The modernization pressure that had been abstract, a slow-building frustration of practitioners and a budget-cycle argument inside agency finance offices, became concrete in the span of four weeks. New York's non-launched pilot and Alabama's unfinished county rollout are now the two clearest operational liabilities of the domestic filing landscape.

The second-order market response is already visible. Founders who had planned to form in their home state and accept the inconvenience are increasingly forming in Delaware, Wyoming, or California instead and qualifying in. That pattern will persist past the reopening. A lawyer who spent April 2020 discovering that a Delaware formation took ninety minutes and a New York formation took three weeks does not unlearn the difference when the probate offices reopen. The filing office that could not operate remotely in April 2020 has just lost a cohort of future formations to the offices that could.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.