Incorporator The Journal of U.S. Formation
Start Free Quiz
Editorial 7 MIN READ

The Delaware statutory trust, for people who keep running into it

A 1988 statute that now holds mutual funds, mortgage pools, and most of the 1031 real-estate market

The Editors
Staff, Incorporator.org
7 min read Updated
Contents 5 sections
  1. What it is, and when to pick one
  2. Formation mechanics
  3. Tax treatment
  4. Failure modes
  5. Sources

Delaware statutory trust is an entity you have probably used without noticing. If your 401(k) owns a mutual fund, the fund itself is very often a DST. If you bought into a 1031 exchange last year, the sponsor's vehicle was almost certainly a DST. The form is the quiet workhorse of American structured finance, and most founders never form one until a tax lawyer tells them they must.

This is a primer on what the entity actually is, when it is the right pick, and the few places it quietly fails.

What it is, and when to pick one

The Delaware Statutory Trust Act sits at 12 Del. C. Chapter 38. It started life as the Delaware Business Trust Act in 1988, when the General Assembly passed it to give structured-finance lawyers a purpose-built alternative to the common-law business trust. In 2002 the General Assembly renamed it the Statutory Trust Act, in part to stop anyone from confusing it with a Subchapter J grantor trust or with an Internal Revenue Code §7701(a) business trust. The statute's definitions section, 12 Del. C. § 3801, now defines a "statutory trust" as an unincorporated association formed by filing a certificate of trust under § 3810. That filing is what brings the entity into being; the trust agreement is what governs it.

The three situations where the form earns its keep are narrow and specific.

The first is securitization. A DST can hold a pool of mortgages, receivables, or equipment leases while remaining bankruptcy-remote from its sponsor. 12 Del. C. § 3804 lets the trust sue and be sued in its own name and permits a series structure in which debts of one series are enforceable only against that series' assets, which is exactly what an asset-backed issuer wants. The statute's freedom-of-contract principle — codified at 12 Del. C. § 3825 — means the trust agreement can impose nearly any waterfall, any consent right, any transfer restriction the deal calls for. Structured-finance counsel do not pick a DST because it is elegant; they pick it because rating agencies and indenture trustees already know how to diligence it.

The second is registered investment companies. Open-end mutual funds, closed-end funds, and business development companies organized under the Investment Company Act of 1940 have migrated out of Massachusetts business trusts and Maryland corporations and into Delaware statutory trusts over the last two decades. The reasons are operational. A DST can skip shareholder meetings where the 1940 Act does not require them, can add or terminate series by trustee action, and can put its entire governance architecture — from board composition to shareholder-vote thresholds — into a private trust agreement that is never filed with the state. For a fund family spinning up a new sub-advised strategy every quarter, the difference between a Delaware series trust and a Maryland corporate series is weeks of work and several meetings of a board of directors.

The third, and by 2017 the most visible to the retail public, is §1031 like-kind exchange investing. In Rev. Rul. 2004-86 the IRS held that a beneficial interest in a properly structured DST is treated as a direct interest in the underlying real estate for §1031 purposes. That ruling is the entire economic reason the DST sponsor market exists. An investor selling an apartment building can exchange into fractional DST interests across a handful of institutional-grade properties instead of shopping for a single replacement on a 45-day identification clock. The trade-off is the ruling's so-called seven deadly sins: to keep the grantor-trust treatment, the trustee cannot renegotiate leases, cannot refinance the property's debt, cannot accept new capital contributions after the closing, cannot reinvest sale proceeds, cannot make more than minor non-structural improvements, cannot dispose of and replace assets, and cannot change the terms of existing financing. A DST that violates any of these springs becomes a partnership for tax purposes, and every investor's §1031 treatment evaporates. Sponsors structure around this with a "springing LLC" provision that converts the trust into an LLC before a workout, at which point the 1031 treatment is already banked.

Formation mechanics

Formation is a one-page exercise. You file a Certificate of Trust with the Delaware Division of Corporations under 12 Del. C. § 3810 stating the trust's name and the name and business address of at least one Delaware trustee. If no trustee is a Delaware resident or entity, the trust must have a registered office and a registered agent in Delaware under § 3807. The Division's filing fee for the certificate is in the low-hundreds range, well below what a new LLC in most states pays in annual-report fees. The certificate does not contain the beneficial owners' names, the capital structure, or the trust agreement itself; all of that lives in a private document that never gets filed.

The trust agreement is the functional equivalent of an LLC's operating agreement, and it is where every real decision sits. It names the trustees, it allocates economics, it sets consent rights, and it specifies how and when the trust terminates. For a securitization or fund trust it is usually a hundred pages; for a closely held family trust it can be ten. 12 Del. C. § 3806 gives the drafter near-complete latitude to modify default fiduciary duties, which is one of the main reasons sophisticated parties use the form.

Delaware does not impose an annual franchise tax or annual-report obligation on statutory trusts. The state's corporate franchise tax and the $300 flat tax on LLCs and LPs do not reach them. The maintenance cost is the registered-agent fee and whatever the trustee charges, which for a Delaware-resident institutional trustee is a meaningful annual number but one that deal economics absorb without complaint.

Tax treatment

The default federal tax classification depends on how the trust is structured. A DST holding passive real estate with no management discretion — the classic §1031 structure — is a grantor trust under Subchapter J, and each beneficial owner reports a pro-rata share of the trust's income and deductions directly. A DST with active business operations is a business entity under Treas. Reg. § 301.7701-4(b) and elects its classification under the check-the-box rules at § 301.7701-3: it can be an association taxed as a C-corporation, a partnership, or, if single-owner, a disregarded entity. Registered investment companies organized as DSTs file their own returns as regulated investment companies under IRC Subchapter M once they qualify and elect under IRC § 851.

The state tax picture is narrow. Delaware does not tax DSTs as entities, and the beneficial owners' state-level treatment turns on where they live and where the underlying assets sit. A Texas investor in a California apartment-building DST files a California non-resident return on her share of the rents; Delaware sees none of it.

Failure modes

The form fails in two places. The first is the §1031 sponsor deal that hits economic trouble. Because the trustee cannot refinance or renegotiate, a DST holding a single property with a balloon maturity coming due has only two options: sell the property or convert to an LLC under the springing provision. Investors who bought the DST because they did not want active real-estate management suddenly find themselves LLC members deciding whether to put in more capital, which is not what they signed up for.

The second is the assumption that the trust agreement's freedom of contract covers everything. It does not cover federal securities law, ERISA, or the 1940 Act, and DSTs routinely hold assets and owners that trigger all three. The common failure pattern is a sponsor who drafted a beautiful trust agreement and did not get 1940 Act counsel until after the marketing started.

If you are forming a DST because your counsel told you to, your counsel is almost certainly right, and the specific mechanics above will look familiar. If you are forming one because an article described it as an all-purpose vehicle, stop. The DST is a specialist's tool. Outside the three use cases, an LLC is cheaper, simpler, and understood by more lenders.

Sources

Keep reading

More from the journal.